The term ‘nursing process’ was originated in 1955 by Hall and later used by Johnson (1959), Orlando (1961), and Weidenbach (1963).
The purpose of the nursing process is to identify a client's health status and his/her actual or potential health care problems or needs, to establish plans to meet the identified needs, and to deliver specific nursing interventions to meet these needs. The client may be an individual, a family or a group.
The use of nursing process in clinical practice gained additional legitimacy in 1973 when it was included in the American Nurses Association's (ANA), Standards of Clinical Nursing Practice. The standards of care include the five phases of nursing process: Assessment, diagnosis, planning, implementation, and evaluation. The different phases of nursing process are closely interrelated and each phase affects the others. For example, if inadequate data are obtained during assessing, the nursing diagnosis will be incomplete or incorrect; and the inaccuracy will also be reflected in the planning, implementing and evaluating phases.
The nursing process is a systematic, rational method of planning and providing nursing care. The nursing process is cyclical; that is, its components follow a logical sequence, and more than one component may be involved at one time. At the end of the cycle, care may be terminated if goals are achieved, or the cycle may continue with reassessment, or the plan of care may be modified.
THE FIVE PHASES OF NURSING PROCESS
Assessing
Assessing is the systematic and continuous collection, organization, validation, and documentation of data/information for the purpose of establishing a database about the client's responses to health concerns or illness and the ability to manage health care needs. In effect, assessing is a continuous process carried out during all phases of the nursing process. For example, in the evaluation phase assessment is done to determine the outcomes of the nursing strategies and to evaluate goal achievement.
There are four types of assessments; initial assessment, problem-focused assessment, emergency assessment and time-lapsed assessment. Assessments vary according to their purpose, time available and client status.
- Initial assessment is performed within specified time after admission to a health care agency, such as the admission assessment. The purpose is to establish a complete database for problem identification, reference and future comparison.
- Problem-focused assessment is an ongoing process integrated with nursing care. It is done to determine the status of a specific problem identified in an earlier assessment and to identify new or overlooked problems. An example for this would be the assessment of a client's ability to perform self-care while assisting him to bathe.
- Emergency assessment is done during any physiologic or psychologic crisis of the client. The purpose is to identify life-threatening problems. For example rapid assessment of a person's airway, breathing status and circulation during a cardiac arrest or assessment of suicidal tendencies or potential for violence in a psychiatric patient.
- Time-lapsed assessment—this is done several months after initial assessment. The purpose is to compare the client's current status to baseline data previously obtained. Reassessment of a client's functional health 4patterns in a home care or outpatient setting or in hospital at shift change are examples of time-lapsed assessment.
Collecting Data
Data collection is the process of gathering information about a client's health status. It must be both systematic and continuous to prevent the omission of significant data and reflect a client's changing status.
A Database
It is all the information about a client; it includes the nursing health history, physical assessment, the physician's health history and physical examination, results of laboratory and diagnostic tests and material contributed by other health personnel.
Client data should include past history as well as current problems. For example, a history of an allergic reaction to penicillin and chronic diseases are important historical data. Current data relate to present circumstances, such as pain, nausea and sleep patterns.
Type of Data
Data can be subjective or objective.
Subjective data are also referred to as symptoms or covert data. These are apparent only to the person affected and can be reported or described only by that person or client. Pain, anxiety and fear are examples of subjective data. Client's sensation, feelings, values, beliefs, attitudes and perceptions of health status are all subjective data.
Objective data are referred to as signs or overt data, which are detectable by an observer or can be measured or tested against an acceptable standard. This can be seen, heard, felt or smelled and they are obtained by observation or physical examination. For example, a discoloration of the skin or a blood pressure reading is objective data. During physical examination, the nurse obtains objective data to validate subjective data and to complete the assessment phase of the nursing process.
A complete database of both subjective and objective data provides a baseline for comparing the client's responses to nursing and medical interventions.
Sources of Data
Sources of data are primary and secondary. The client is the primary source of data. Family members, other support persons, other health professionals, records and reports, laboratory and diagnostic analyses, and relevant literature are secondary sources.
The best source of data is usually the client, unless the client is too ill, young, or confused to commun-icate clearly. The client can provide subjective data that no one else can offer. Family members, friends and care givers who know the client well often can supplement or verify information provided by the client. Support people are especially important source of data for a client who is very young, unconscious, or confused.
Client records serve as good source of data. They contain data regarding the client's occupation, religion, and marital status. Type of client records include medical records, records of therapies and laboratory records. Medical records are often a source of a client's present and past health and illness patterns. These records can provide nurses with information about the client's coping behaviors, health practices, previous illnesses and allergies.
Records of therapies provided by other health professionals such as social workers, nutritionists, dietitians or physical therapists help the nurse obtain relevant data not expressed by the client.
Laboratory records also provide pertinent health information. For example, the determination of blood glucose level allows health professionals to monitor the administration of hypoglycemic agents.
Reports from other health care professionals serve as other potential sources of information about a client's health. Nurses, social workers, physicians and physiotherapists may have information from either previous or current contact with the client. Both verbal and written reports of health care professionals add to data regarding client.
Review of nursing and related literature, such as professional journals, and reference texts can provide additional information for the database.
Data Collection Methods
The methods used to collect data are observing, interviewing and examining. Observation occurs 5whenever the nurse is in contact with the client or support persons. Interviewing is used mainly while taking the nursing health history. Examining is the major method used in the physical health assessment. In reality, the nurse uses all three methods simultaneously when assessing clients. For example, during the client interview the nurse observes, listens, asks questions, and mentally retains information to explore in the physical examination.
Observing
To observe is to gather data by using the senses. Observation is a conscious, deliberate skill that is developed through effort and through an organized approach.
Although nurses observe mainly through sight, most of the senses are engaged during careful observations.
Observation has two aspects (a) noticing data and (b) selecting, organizing and interpreting the data. A nurse who observes that a client's face is flushed must relate that observation to, for example, body temperature, activity, environmental temperature and blood pressure. Nursing observations must be organized so that nothing significant is missed.
Interviewing
An interview is a planned communication or a conversation with a purpose. There are two approaches to interviewing: directive and non-directive. The directive interview is highly structured and elicits specific information. The nurse establishes the purpose of the interview and controls the interview, at least at the outset. The client responds to questions, but may have limited opportunity to ask questions or discuss concerns. Nurses frequently use directive interview in emergency situations.
During a non-directive interview, or rapport-building interview, by contrast, the nurse allows the client to control the purpose, subject matter and pacing. Rapport is an understanding between two or more people. A combination of directive and non-directive approach is usually appropriate during the information-gathering interview.
Examining
The physical examination or physical assessment is a systematic data-collection method that uses observation (i.e., the sense of sight, hearing, smell and touch) to detect health problems. To conduct the examination, the nurse uses techniques of inspection, auscultation, palpation and percussion. Alternatively, the nurse may perform a screening examination. A screening examination, also called a review of systems, is a brief review of essential functioning of various body parts or systems. An example of a screening examination is the nursing admission assessment.
Validating Data
The information gathered during the assessment phase must be complete, factual and accurate because the nursing diagnoses and interventions are based on this information. Validation is the act of “double-checking” or verifying data to confirm that it is accurate and factual.
To build an accurate database, nurses must validate assumptions regarding the client's physical or emotional behavior. For example, a nurse seeing a man holding his arm to his chest might assume that he is experiencing chest pain, when in fact he has a painful hand.
Documenting Data
To complete the assessment phase, the nurse records client data. Accurate documentation is essential and should include all data collected about the client's health status. Data are recorded in a factual manner and not interpreted by the nurse. In order to increase accuracy, the nurse records subjective data in the client's own words.
Diagnosis
Diagnosing is the second phase of the nursing process. In this phase, nurses use critical-thinking skills to interpret assessment data and identify client's strengths and problems. Diagnosis is a pivotal step in the nursing process. All activities preceding this phase are directed toward formulating the nursing diagnosis; all the care-planning activities following this phase are based on the nursing diagnoses.
The identification and development of nursing diagnoses began formally in 1973, when two faculty members of Saint Louis University, Kristine Gebbie and Mary Ann Lavin, perceived a need to identify nurses' roles in an ambulatory care setting. The first National 6Conference to identify nursing diagnoses was sponsored by the Saint Louis University School of Nursing in 1973. Subsequent national conferences occurred in 1975, 1980 and every 2 years thereafter.
International recognition came with the first Canadian Conference in Toronto in 1977 and the international nursing conference in May 1987 in Calgary, Alberta, Canada. In 1982, the conference group accepted the name “North American Nursing Diagnosis Association (NANDA)”, recognizing the participation and contributions of nurses in the United States and Canada.
The purpose of NANDA is to define, refine, and promote a taxonomy of nursing diagnostic terminology for general use by professional nurses. Taxonomy is a classification system or set of categories arranged on the basis of a single principle or set of principles. The group has currently approved more than 150 nursing diagnosis labels for clinical use.
Definitions
The term diagnosing refers to the reasoning process whereas the term diagnosis is a statement or conclusion regarding the nature of a phenomenon. The standardized NANDA names for the diagnoses are called diagnostic labels; and the client's problem statement, consisting the diagnostic label plus etiology (casual relationship between a problem and its related or risk factors) is called nursing diagnosis.
In 1990, NANDA adopted an official working definition of nursing diagnosis; “a clinical judgment about individual, family, or community responses to actual and potential health problems or life processes. Nursing diagnosis provides the basis for selection of nursing interventions to achieve outcomes for which the nurse is accountable”. This definition implies the following:
- Professional nurses (registered nurses) are responsible for making nursing diagnoses, even though other nursing personnel may contribute data to the process of diagnosing and may implement specified nursing care. Nurses are accountable for this phase of the nursing process.
- The domain of nursing diagnosis includes only those health states that nurses are educated and licensed to treat.
- A nursing diagnosis is a judgment made only after thorough, systematic data collection.
- Nursing diagnoses describe a continuum of health states: deviations from health, presence of risk factors, and areas of enhanced personal growth.
Types of Nursing Diagnoses
The five types of nursing diagnoses are actual, risk, wellness, possible and syndrome.
- An actual diagnosis is a client problem that is present at the time of the nursing assessment. Example is Ineffective Breathing Pattern. An actual nursing diagnosis is based on the presence of associated signs and symptoms.
- A risk nursing diagnosis is a clinical judgment that a problem does not exist, but the presence of risk factors indicates that a problem is likely to develop unless nurses intervene. For example a client with diabetes or a compromised immune system is at high risk for infection than others. Therefore, the nurse would appropriately use the label Risk for infection to describe the client's health status.
- A wellness diagnosis describes human responses to levels of wellness in an individual, family or community that have a readiness for enhancement. Examples of wellness diagnosis would be “Readiness for enhanced Family coping” or “Readiness for Enhanced Spiritual well-being”.
- A possible nursing diagnosis is one in which evidence about a health problem is incomplete or unclear. A possible diagnosis requires more data either to support or to refute it. For example, an elderly widow who lives alone is admitted to the hospital. The nurse notices that she has no visitors and is pleased with the attention from nursing staff. A nursing diagnosis for the client may be “possible social isolation related to unknown etiology”.
- A syndrome diagnosis is a diagnosis that is associated with a cluster of other diagnoses. Currently six syndrome diagnoses are on the NANDA international list. For example, long-term bedridden clients may experience disuse syndrome. Clusters of diagnosis associated with this syndrome include– Impaired physical mobility, Risk for impaired Tissue Integrity, Risk for activity Intolerance, Risk for Constipation, Impaired Gas Exchange and so on.
Components of a NANDA Nursing Diagnosis
A nursing diagnosis has three components:
- The problem and its definition.
- The etiology, and
- The defining characteristics. Each component serves a specific purpose.
Problem and Definition (Diagnostic Label)
The problem statement, or diagnostic label, describes the client's health problem or response for which nursing therapy is given. It describes the client's health status clearly and concisely in a few words. The purpose of the diagnostic label is to direct the information of client goals and desired outcomes. It may also suggest some nursing interventions.
To be clinically useful, diagnostic labels need to be specific when the word specify follows a NANDA label. The nurse states the area in which the problem occurs, for example, Deficient Knowledge (Medications) or Deficient Knowledge (Dietary Modifications)
Qualifiers
These are words that have been added to some NANDA labels to give additional meaning to the diagnostic statement. For example:
- Deficient (inadequate in amount, quality or degree; not sufficient; incomplete).
- Impaired (made worse, weakened, damaged, reduced, deteriorated).
- Decreased (lesser in size, amount or degree).
- Ineffective (not producing the desired effect).
- Compromised (to make vulnerable or threat)
Etiology (Related Factors and Risk Factors)
The etiology component of a nursing diagnosis identifies one or more probable causes of the health problem, gives direction to the required nursing interventions and enables the nurse to individualize the client's care. For example, the probable causes of activity intolerance include sedentary life style, generalized weakness, bed rest or immobility. Differentiating among possible causes in the nursing diagnosis is essential because each may require different nursing interventions.
Defining Characteristics
Defining characteristics are the cluster of signs and symptoms that indicate the presence of a particular diagnostic label. For actual nursing diagnoses, the defining characteristics are the client's signs and symptoms. For risk nursing diagnoses, no subjective and objective signs are present. Thus, the factors that cause the client to be more than “normally” vulnerable to the problem form the etiology of a risk nursing diagnosis.
Differentiating Nursing Diagnoses from Medical Diagnoses
A nursing diagnosis is a statement of nursing judgment and refers to a condition that nurses are licensed to treat.
A medical diagnosis is made by physician and refers to a condition that only a physician can treat. Medical diagnoses refer to disease processes specific pathophysiologic responses that are fairly uniform from one client to another. In contrast, nursing diagnoses describe a client's physical, socio-cultural, psychological and spiritual responses to an illness or a health problem.
A client's medical diagnosis remains the same for as long as the disease process is present, but nursing diagnosis changes as the client's responses change. Nurses have responsibilities related to both medical and nursing diagnoses. Nursing diagnoses relate to the nurse's independent functions, that is, the areas of health care that are unique to nursing and separate and distinct from medical management.
The Diagnostic Process
The diagnostic process uses the critical thinking skills of analysis, and synthesis. Critical thinking is a cognitive process during which a person reviews data and considers explanation before forming an opinion. The diagnostic process has three steps:
- Analyzing data
- Identifying health problems, risks and strengths, and
- Formulating diagnostic statement.
Formulating Diagnostic Statements
Most nursing diagnosis are written as two-part or three-part statements.
- Basic two-part statements include the following:
- Problem (P): Statement of the client's response (NANDA label).
- Etiology (E) factors contributing to or probable causes of the responses.
The two parts are joined by the words related to rather than due to. The phrase due to implies that one 8part causes or is responsible for the other part. By contrast, the phrase related to, merely implies a relationship. Examples of two-part nursing diagnosis are:
- Constipation related to irregular defecation habits.
- Ineffective breastfeeding related to breast engorgement.
Some NANDA labels contain the word specify. For these, the nurse must add words to indicate the problem more specifically. For example: Noncompliance (specify). Noncompliance (Diabetic diet) related to denial of having disease.
- Basic three-part statements:The basic three part nursing diagnosis statement is the PES format and includes the following:
- Problem (P): Statement of the client's response (NANDA label).
- Etiology (E): Factors contributing to or probable causes of the response.
- Signs and symptoms (S): Defining characteristics manifested by the client.
Example:
- Ineffective coping related to labor and delivery as evidenced by fatigue and expressed inability to cope.
- Deficient fluid volume related to postpartum hemorrhage as evidenced by decreased pulse volume and pressure.
Actual nursing diagnoses can be documented by using the three-part statement because the signs and symptoms have been identified. The format cannot be used for risk diagnoses because the client does not have signs and symptoms of the diagnosis.
In addition to using the correct format, nurses must consider the content of their diagnostic statements. The statements should, for example, be accurate, concise, descriptive, and specific. The nurse must always validate the diagnostic statements with the client and compare the clients' signs and symptoms to the NANDA defining characteristics. For risk factors, the nurse compares the client's risk factors to NANDA risk factors.
- One-part statements
Some diagnostic statements, such as wellness diagnosis and syndrome nursing diagnosis, consist of a NANDA label only. As the diagnostic labels are refined, they tend to become more specific, so that nursing interventions can be derived from the label itself. Therefore, an etiology may not be needed. For example, adding an etiology to the label Rape-Trauma Syndrome does not make the label any more descriptive or useful.
NANDA has specified that any new wellness diagnoses will be developed as one-part statements beginning with the words Readiness for enhanced followed by the desired higher level wellness. For example, Readiness for Enhanced Parenting.
Currently the NANDA list includes several wellness diagnoses. Some of these are: Spiritual Well Being, Effective Breast Feeding, Health Seeking Behaviours, and Anticipatory grieving. These are usually accepted as one-part statements, but may be made more explicit by adding a descriptor, for example, Health Seeking Behaviours (Low Fat Diet).
Variations of Basic Formats
Variations of the basic, one, two and three part statements include the following:
- Writing the terms unknown etiology, when the defining characteristics are present but the nurse does not know the cause or contributing factors. For example, Noncompliance (Medication Regimen) related to unknown etiology.
- Using the phrase complex factors, when there are too many etiologic factors or when they are too complex to state in a brief phrase. The actual causes of chronic low self-esteem, for instance, may be long-term and complex, as in the following nursing diagnosis chronic low self-esteem related to complex factors.
- Using the word possible to describe either the problem or the etiology. When the nurse believes more data are needed about the client's problem or the etiology, the word possible is used. Examples are: Possible low self-esteem related to loss of job and rejection by family. Altered thought Process possibly related to unfamiliar surroundings.
- Using the word secondary to divide the etiology into two parts; thereby making the statement more descriptive and useful. The part following secondary to is often pathophysiologic or disease process as in Risk for Impaired Skin Integrity related to decreased peripheral circulation secondary to diabetes.
- Adding a secondary part to the general response or NANDA label, to make it more precise. For example, the diagnosis Impaired Skin Integrity (left lateral ankle) related to decreased peripheral circulation.
Avoiding Errors in Diagnostic Reasoning
It is important that nurses make nursing diagnoses with a high level of accuracy. Nurses can avoid some common errors of reasoning by recognizing them and applying appropriate critical-thinking skills. Errors can occur at any point in the diagnostic process: data collection, data interpretation and data clustering. The following steps help to minimize diagnostic errors.
- Verify: Hypothesize possible explanations of the data, but realize that all diagnoses are tentative until they are verified. Begin and end the process by talking with the client and family. Ask them what their health problems are and what they believe the causes to be. At the end of the process have them verify your diagnoses.
- Build a good knowledge base and acquire clinical experience. Nurse must apply knowledge from many different areas (applied sciences) to recognize significant cues and patterns and generate a hypothesis about the data. For example, principles from chemistry, anatomy, and pharmacology each help the nurse understand client data.
- Have a working knowledge of what is normal. Nurses need to know the normal physiological parameters for vital signs, laboratory tests, breath sounds and so on. In addition, she must determine what is normal for a particular person taking into accounts of his or her age, physical make up, life style, and physiological changes such as pregnancy.
- Consult resources: Both freshers and experienced nurses should consult appropriate resources, whenever in doubt about a diagnosis. Professional literature, nursing colleagues and nurse educators are all appropriate resources. Use of a nursing diagnosis handbook for quick reference will be useful too.
- Improve critical thinking skills. These skills help the nurse to be aware of and avoid errors in thinking, such as over generalizing, stereotyping and making unwarranted assumptions.
Guidelines for Writing Nursing Diagnostic Statements
-
State in terms of a problem not a need.Correct: Deficient fluid volume (problem) related to fever.Incorrect: Fluid replacement (need) related to fever.
-
Word the statement so that it is legally acceptable.Correct: Impaired skin integrity related to immobility (legally acceptable).Incorrect: Impaired skin integrity related to improper positioning (implies legal liability).
- Use non-judgmental statements.Correct: Spiritual distress related to inability to attend church services secondary to immobility (nonjudgmental).Incorrect: Spiritual distress related to strict rules requiring regular church attendance (judgmental).
- Make sure that both elements of the statement do not say the same thing.Correct: Risk for impaired skin integrity related to immobility.Incorrect: Impaired skin integrity related to ulceration of sacral area.(Problem and probable cause are the same)
- Be sure that problem and etiology are correctly statedCorrect: Pain: Severe headache related to fear of addiction to narcotics.Incorrect: Pain related to severe headache.
- Word the diagnosis specifically and precisely to provide direction for planning nursing interventions.Correct: Impaired oral mucous membrane related to decreased salivation secondary to radiation of neck (specific).Incorrect: Impaired oral mucous membrane related to noxious agent (vague).
- Use nursing terminology rather than medical terminology to describe the client's response.Correct: Risk for ineffective airway clearance related to accumulation of secretions in lungs (nursing terminology).Incorrect: Risk for pneumonia (medical terminology).
Planning
Planning is the third phase of the nursing process, in which the nurse and client develop client goals/ desired outcomes and nursing interventions to prevent, reduce or alleviate the client's health problems.
Planning is a deliberate, systematic process that involves decision-making and problem solving. In planning, the nurse refers to the client's assessment data and diagnostic statements for direction in formulating client goals and designing the nursing interventions required to manage the clients' health problems.10
A nursing intervention is any treatment, based on clinical judgment and knowledge that a nurse performs to enhance patient/client outcomes.
Although planning is basically a nurse's responsibility, input from the client and support person (family members) is essential if a plan is to be effective. Nurses do not plan for the client, but encourage the client to participate actively to the extent possible. In a home setting, the client's family members and caregivers are the ones who implement the plan of care, thus its effectiveness depends largely on them.
Types of Planning
Planning begins with the first client contact and continues until the nurse-client relationship ends, usually when the client is discharged from the hospital.
- Initial planning: The nurse who performs the admission assessment usually develops the initial, plan of care. This nurse uses the client's body language, as well as some intuitive kinds of information that are not solely available from written database. Planning should be initiated as soon as possible after the initial assessment.
- Ongoing planning: All nurses who work with the client do ongoing planning. As nurses obtain new information and evaluate the client's responses to care, they can individualize the initial care plan further. Ongoing planning also occurs at the beginning of a shift as the nurse plans the care to be given that day/that shift. The nurse carries out the daily planning in order to:
- Determine whether the client's health status has changed
- Set priorities for the client's care during the shift
- Decide which problems to focus on during the shift
- Coordinate nurse's activities so that more than one problem can be addressed at each client contact.
- Discharge planning: Discharge planning is the process of anticipating and planning for needs after discharge. This is a crucial part of comprehensive health care and should be addressed in each client's care plan. For patients who are discharged early – before complete recovery, such care is delivered in the home. Effective discharge planning begins at first contact with client and involves comprehen-sive and ongoing assessment to obtain information about client's ongoing needs.
Developing Nursing Care Plans
The end product of the planning phase of the nursing process is a formal or informal plan of care.
- An informal nursing care plan is a strategy for action that exists in the nurse's mind. For example, the nurse may think “Mrs. Ramu is very tired, I will reinforce her teaching after she is rested”.
- A formal nursing care plan is a written or computerized guide that organizes information about the client's care. The benefit of a formal written care plan is that it provides for continuity of care.
- A standardized care plan is a formal plan that specifies the nursing cares for groups of clients with common needs (example, all clients with eclamptic fits).
- An individualized care plan is tailored to meet the unique needs of a specific client those are needs that are not addressed by the standardized plan.
Nurses use the formal care plan for direction about what needs to be documented in client's progress notes and as a guide for delegating and assigning staff to care for clients.When nursing diagnoses are used to develop goals and nursing interventions, the result is a holistic, individualized plan of care that will meet the client's unique needs.
Care plans include the actions nurses must take to address the client's nursing diagnoses and produce the desired outcome. The nurse begins the plan when the client is admitted to the hospital and constantly updates it throughout the client's stay in response to changes in the client's condition and evaluations of goal achievement.
The complete plan of care for a client is made up of several different documents that:
- Describe the routine care needed to meet basic needs such as bathing and nutrition.
- Address the client's nursing diagnoses and collaborative problems and
- Specify nursing responsibilities in carrying out the medical plan of care (e.g. scheduling laboratory tests, keeping client from eating or drinking before surgery). A complete plan of care integrates dependent and independent nursing functions.
Standardized Approaches to Care Planning
Standards of care, standardized care plans, protocols, policies and procedures are developed and accepted by nursing staff in order to ensure that minimum acceptable standards for patient care are met and to promote efficient use of nurses' time.12
Standardized care plans are pre-printed guides for the nursing care of a client who has a need that arises frequently in the agency (e.g. specific nursing diagnosis or all nursing diagnoses associated with a particular medical condition). They are written from the perspective of what care the client can expect.
Standardized Care Plans
- Are kept with the client's individualized care plan on the nursing unit, probably in the ‘kardex’. When the client is discharged, they become part of the permanent medical record.
- Provide detailed interventions and contain additions or deletions from the standards of care of the agency.
- Are written in the nursing process format:
Problem → Desired outcomes / goals → Nursing interventions → Evaluations
Like standardized care plans, protocols are pre-printed to indicate the actions commonly required for a particular group of clients. For example, a hospital may have a protocol for admitting a client to the intensive care unit, for administering magnesium sulphate to a client with pre-eclampsia/eclampsia or for caring for a client receiving continuous epidural analgesia. Protocols may include both physician's orders and nursing interventions.
Policies and procedures are developed to govern the handling of frequently occurring situations. For example, a hospital may have a policy specifying the number of visitors a patient may have. Some policies and procedures specify what is to be done, for example, in the case of cardiac arrest. If a policy covers a situation pertinent to client care, it is usually entered in the care plan (e.g. make social service referral according policy manual). Policies are institutional records and do not become a part of the permanent record.
A standing order is a written document about policies, rules, regulations or orders regarding client care. Standing orders give nurses the authority to carry out specific actions under certain circumstances, often when a physician is not immediately available. In a hospital critical care unit, a common example is the administration of emergency antiarrythmic medications when a client's cardiac monitoring pattern changes.
Regardless of whether care plans are handwritten, computerized or standardized, nursing care must be individualized to fit the unique needs of each client. In hospitals/health care settings when nursing process is followed for providing holistic care to clients, care plans usually consist of both preprinted and handwritten sections. The nurse uses standardized care plans for predictable, commonly occurring problems and handwrites an individual plan for unusual problems or problems needing special attention. For example, a standardized care plan for all “clients with a medical diagnosis of pneumonia” would probably include a nursing diagnosis of deficient fluid volume, and direct the nurse to assess the client's hydration status. On a respiratory or medical unit, this would be a common nursing diagnosis and the nurse may incorporate it in her care plan for the client. However, a nursing diagnosis, risk for interrupted family process would not be common to all patients with pneumonia, it is true only to certain clients. Therefore the goals and nursing interventions for that diagnosis would need to be handwritten by the nurse.
Formats for Nursing Care Plan
Formats of care plan written by working nurses or practicing nurses in hospital units are often organized into four columns or categories:
- Nursing diagnoses
- Goals/desired outcomes
- Nursing orders/interventions, and
- Evaluations.
Student care plans are more lengthy and detailed as it is a learning activity as well as plan of care. They usually have an additional column for “rationale” after nursing orders column. To help students learn to write care plans, these are often handwritten as required by the educators. A rationale is a scientific principle given as the reason for selecting a particular nursing intervention. Students may also be required to cite supporting literature for their stated rationale.
Guidelines for Writing Nursing Care Plans
The nurse should use the following guidelines for writing care plans.
- Date and sign the plan: The date, the plan is written is essential for evaluation. The nurse's signature demonstrates accountability to the client and to the nursing profession.
- Use Category headings: Different columns of the record form should have headings such as “Nursing diagnoses”, “Desired outcomes / goals”, “Nursing interventions” and “Evaluation”. Include a date for evaluation of each goal.
- Be specific: Write specific time or instruction for nursing interventions. For example, “change incisional dressing q shift” may mean 2 dressing changes for 12-hour duty shifts and 3 dressing changes for 8-hour duty shifts.
- Tailor the plan to the unique characteristics of the client by ensuring that the client's preferences and choices are considered: This reinforces the client's individuality and sense of control. For example, the written nursing intervention “Provide coffee at breakfast rather than tea” indicates that the client was given a choice for his breakfast drink.
- Ensure that the nursing care plan incorporates preventive and health maintenance aspects as well as restorative ones: For example, the nursing directive “provide active assistance for range-of-motion (ROM) exercises to affected limbs q2h” prevents joint contractures and maintains muscle strength and joint mobility.
- Ensure that the plan contains interventions for ongoing assessment of the client: e.g. inspect incision q8h.
- Include collaborative and coordination activities in the plan. For example, “administer p.r.n pain medication as indicated”, “Arrange referral service with social worker”.
- Include plans for client's discharge and home care needs. For example, arrangements with community health nurse, social worker or specific agencies for needed equipment. Add teaching and discharge plans.
- Refer to procedure books or other sources of information for writing selected and appropriate nursing directives.
The Planning Process
The processs of developing care plans include four different activities.
Setting Priorities
This is the process of establishing a preferential sequence for addressing nursing diagnoses and interventions. The nurse and client begin planning by deciding which nursing diagnosis requires attention first, which second and so on. Life threatening problems, such as loss of respiratory or cardiac function are designated as high priority. Health-threatening problems such as acute illness and decreased coping ability are assigned medium priority. A low-priority problem is one that arises from normal developmental needs or that requires only minimal nursing support. Nurses use Maslow's hierarchy of needs when setting priorities. In Maslow's hierarchy, physiologic needs such as air, food and water are basic to life and receive higher priority than the need for security or activity. Thus nursing diagnoses such as Ineffective Airway Clearance and Impaired Gas Exchange would take priority over nursing diagnoses such as Anxiety or Ineffective Coping.
It is not necessary to resolve all high-priority diagnoses before addressing others. The nurse may partially address a high-priority diagnosis and then deal with a diagnosis of lesser priority. Further, because the clients usually have several problems, the nurse often deals with more than one diagnosis at a time.
Establishing Desired Outcomes / Client Goals
After establishing priorities, the nurse and client set goals for each nursing diagnosis. The desired outcome sentences describe, in terms of observable client responses, what the nurse hopes to achieve by implementing the nursing interventions. The terms desired outcomes and goals are used interchangeably. These are stated as specific, observable criteria and used to evaluate whether the goals have been met. For example“Improved nutritional status as evidenced by weight gain of 5 lb by April 25”. Writing the broad general goal first, may help students to think of specific outcomes that are needed as a starting point for planning. What needs to be written on the care plan is the specific, observable, outcomes than can be used to evaluate client progress?
Purposes of Desired Outcomes / Goals
Desired outcome serve the following purposes:
- Provide direction for planning nursing interventions. Ideas for interventions come more easily, if the desired outcomes state clearly and specifically what the nurse hopes to achieve.
- Serve as criteria for judging the effectiveness of nursing interventions and client progress in the evaluation step.
- Enable the client and nurse to determine when the problem has been resolved.
- Help motivate the client and nurse by providing a sense of achievement. As goals are met, both client and nurse can see that their efforts have been worthwhile.
Guidelines for Writing Desired Outcomes / Goals
The following guidelines can help nurses write useful goals and desired outcomes:
- Write goals and outcomes in terms of client responses, not nurse activities. Beginning each statement with the client will may help to focus the goal on client behaviours and responses. Avoid statements that start with enable, facilitate, allow, let, permit or similar verbs followed by the word client. These indicate what the nurse hopes to accomplish and not what the client will do.
- Correct: Client will drink 100 ml of water per hour (client behaviour).
- Incorrect: Maintain client hydration (nursing action).
- Be sure that desired outcomes are realistic for the client's capabilities, limitations and designated time span, if it is indicated. Limitations refer to finances, equipment, family support, physical and mental condition and time. For example, the outcome “Measures insulin accurately” may be unrealistic for a client who has poor vision due to cataract.
- Ensure that the desired outcomes are compatible with the therapies of other professionals. For example, the outcome “will increase the time spent out of bed by 15 minutes each day” is not compatible with a physician's prescribed therapy of bed rest.
- Use observable, measurable terms for outcomes. Avoid words that are vague and require interpretation or judgment by observer. For example, phrases such as ‘increase daily exercise’, and ‘improve knowledge of nutrition’ can mean differently to different people. These are not sufficiently clear and specific to guide the nurse when evaluating client responses.
- Make sure the client considers the desired outcomes important and values them. Some outcomes, such as those problems related to self-esteem, parenting, and communication involve choices that are best made by the client or in collaboration with the client.
- The nurse must actively listen to the client to determine personal values, goals, and desired outcomes in relation to current health concerns. Clients are usually motivated and expend the necessary energy to reach goals they consider important.
Computerized Care Plans
Computers are being used in recent years to create and store nursing care plans. The computer can generate both standardized and individualized care plans. Nurses access the client's stored care plan from a centrally located terminal at the nurses' station. For an individualized plan, the nurse chooses the appropriate diagnoses from a menu suggested by the computer. The computer then lists possible goals and nursing interventions for those diagnoses; the nurse chooses those appropriate for the client and types in any additional goals and interventions or nursing actions not listed on the menu. The nurse can read the plan on the computer screen or get a print out of the updated working copy.
NURSING INTERVENTIONS
Nursing interventions are the actions to achieve client goals. The specific interventions chosen should focus on eliminating or reducing the etiology of the nursing diagnosis, which is the second clause of the diagnostic statement.
When it is not possible to change the etiologic factors, the nurse chooses interventions to treat the signs and symptoms or the defining characteristics in NANDA terminology. Examples of this situation would be pain related to surgical incision and anxiety related to unknown etiology.
Interventions for risk nursing diagnosis should focus on measures to reduce the client's risk factors, which are also found in the second clause. Correct identification of the etiology during the diagnosing phase provides the framework for choosing successful nursing interventions. For example, the diagnostic label Activity Intolerance may have several etiologies: pain, weakness, sedentary lifestyle, anxiety, or cardiac arrhythmias. Interventions will vary according to the cause of the problem.
Types of Nursing Interventions
Nursing interventions are identified and written during the planning step of the nursing process; however, they are actually performed during the implementing step. Nursing interventions include both direct and indirect 15care, as well as nurse-initiated, physician-initiated and other provider-initiated treatments. Direct care is an intervention performed through interaction with the client. Indirect care is an intervention performed away from but on behalf of the client such as interdisciplinary collaboration or management of the care environment.
Independent Interventions
Independent interventions are those activities that nurses are licensed to initiate on the basis of their knowledge and skills. They include physical care, ongoing assessment, emotional support and comfort, teaching, counseling, environmental management, and making referrals to other health care professionals. In performing an autonomous activity, the nurse determines that the client requires certain nursing interventions; either carries these out or delegates them to other nursing personnel, and is accountable or answerable for the decisions and the actions. An example of an independent action is planning and providing special mouth care for a client after diagnosing Impaired Oral Mucous Membranes.
Dependent Interventions
Dependent interventions are activities carried out under the physician's orders or supervision, or according to specified routines. Physician's orders commonly include orders for medications, intravenous therapy, diagnostic tests, diet, and activity. The nurse is responsible for explaining, assessing the need for, and administering the medical orders. Nursing interventions may be written to individualize the medical order based on the client's status. For example, for a medical order to “Progressive ambulation, as tolerated” a nurse might write the following:
- Dangle for 5 min., 12 hr post op.
- Stand at bedside 24 hrs post op.: observe for pallor and dizziness.
- Check pulse before and after ambulating. Do not progress if pulse rate is > 110 / min.
Collaborative Interventions
These are actions the nurse carries out in collaboration with other health team members, such as physical therapists, social workers, dieticians and physicians. Collaborative nursing activities reflect the overlapping responsibilities of and collegial relationships between, health personnel. For example, the physician might order physical therapy to teach the client crutch walking. The nurse would be responsible for informing the physical therapy department and for coordinating the client's care to include the physical therapy sessions. When the client returns to nursing unit, the nurse would assist with crutch watching and collaborate with the physical therapist to evaluate the client's progress.
Writing Nursing Orders
After choosing the appropriate nursing interventions, the nurse writes them on the nursing care plan as nursing orders. Nursing orders are instructions for the specific, individualized activities the nurse performs to help the client meet established health care goals. The term order con notes a sense of accountability for the nurse who gives the order and for the nurse who carries it out. Components of nursing orders are Date, Action verb, Content area, Time element and Signature.
Example: 15/08/2007 Palpate uterine fundus for firmness, hourly twice, then q4h for 24 hours, A Jones, RN”.
Date
Nursing orders are dated when they are written and reviewed regularly at intervals depending on the individual's needs. In an intensive care unit, for example, the plan of care will be continually monitored and revised. In a community health clinic, weekly or biweekly reviews may be indicated.
Action Verb
The action verb starts the order and must be precise. For example, “Explain (to the client) the actions of insulin” is a more precise statement than “teach (the client) about insulin”. Sometimes a modifier for the verb can make the nursing order more precise. For example, “apply spiral bandage firmly to left lower leg” is more precise than “Apply spiral bandage to left leg”.
Content Area
The content is, the what and where of the order. In the preceding order, “spiral bandage” and “left leg” state, the what and where of the order. The content area in this example may also clarify whether the foot or toes are to be left exposed.16
Time Element
The time element answers when, how long or how often the nursing action is to occur. Examples are “Assist client with sitz bath at 10 am and 5 pm daily” and “Administer analgesic 30 minutes prior to physical therapy”.
Signature
The signature of the nurse prescribing the order shows the nurse's accountability and has legal significance.
Implementing
The nursing process is client oriented, action oriented, and outcome directed. After developing a plan of care based the assessment and diagnosing phases, the nurse implements the interventions and evaluates the desired outcomes. On the basis of this evaluation, the plan of care is continued, modified or terminated.
In the nursing process, implementing is the phase in which the nurse implements the nursing interventions. Implementing consists of doing and documenting activities that are specific nursing actions needed to carry out nursing orders. The nurse performs or delegates the nursing activities for the interventions that were developed in planning step and then conclude the implementing step by recording nursing activities and the resulting client responses. The degree of participation depends on the client's health status. For example, an unconscious person is unable participate in his care and therefore needs to have care given to him. By contrast, an ambulatory client may require very little care from the nurse and carry out health care activities independently.
Relationship of Implementing to other Phases of Nursing Process
The first three phases of nursing process—assessing, diagnosing and planning provide the basis for nursing actions performed during implementing step. In turn, the implementing phase provides the actual nursing activities and client responses that are examined in the final phase, the evaluating phase.
While implementing nursing orders, the nurse continues to assess the client at every contact, gathering data about the client's responses to the nursing activities and about any new problems that may develop. A nursing activity on the client's care plan may read “Auscultate lungs q4h”. When performing this activity, the nurse is both carrying out the intervention (implementing) and performing an assessment.
Some routine nursing activities are, themselves, assessments. For example, while bathing an elderly client, the nurse observes a reddened area on the client's sacrum. Or, when emptying a urinary catheter bag, the nurse measures 200 ml of strong-smelling, brown urine.
Implementing Skills
To implement the care plan successfully, nurses need cognitive, interpersonal and technical skills. These skills are distinct from one another and nurses use them in various combinations and with different emphasis, depending on the activity. For instance, when inserting a urinary catheter the nurse needs cognitive knowledge of the principles and steps of the procedure, interpersonal skills to inform and reassure client and technical skills in draping the client and manipulating the articles.
The cognitive skills (intellectual skills) include problem solving, decision-making, critical thinking and creativity. They are crucial to safe, intelligent nursing care.
Interpersonal skills are verbal and non-verbal activities people use when interacting directly with one another. The effectiveness of a nursing action often depends largely on the nurse's ability to communicate with others. The nurse uses therapeutic communication to understand the client and in turn be understood. Interpersonal skills are necessary for all nursing activities; caring, comforting, advocating, referring, counseling and supporting. Before nurses can be highly skilled in interpersonal relations, they must have self-awareness and sensitivity to others.
Technical skills are “hands on” skills such as manipulating equipment, giving injections and bandaging, moving, lifting and repositioning clients. The skills are also called as tasks, procedures, or psychomotor skills.
Technical skills require knowledge and manual dexterity. The number of technical skills expected of a nurse has increased in the recent years because of the increased use of technology, especially in acute care hospitals.17
The Process of Implementing
Implementing is the process in which the nurse implements the nursing interventions and documents the care provided. The process includes:
- Reassessing the client.
- Determining the nurse's need for assistance.
- Implementing the nursing interventions.
- Supervising the delegated care and
- Documenting nursing activities.
Reassessing the Client
Before implementing an intervention, the nurse must reassess the client to make sure the intervention is still needed. Even though a nursing order is written on the care plan, the client's condition may have changed. For example, a directive, back message may be written for a nursing diagnosis of Disturbed Sleep Pattern, related to anxiety and unfamiliar surroundings. During her rounds, the nurse discovers that the client is sleeping and therefore defers the back massage that had been planned as a relaxation strategy.
At times new data may indicate a need to change the priorities of care or nursing activities.
Determining the Nurse's Need for Assistance
For implementing some nursing interventions, the nurse may require assistance for the following reasons.
- The nurse is unable to implement the nursing activity safely alone (e.g. ambulating an unsteady, obese client).
- The stress on client would be reduced if nurse arranges for assistance for the activity (e.g. turning a client who experiences acute pain when moved).
- The nurse lacks the skills or knowledge to implement a particular nursing activity (e.g. a nurse who is not familiar with the use of an isolette needs assistance the first time it is used).
Implementing the Nursing Interventions
When implementing nursing interventions, nurses should follow certain guidelines.
- Base nursing interventions on scientific knowledge, professional standards and nursing research (evidence-based practice). The nurse must be aware of scientific rationale, as well as possible side effects or complications of all interventions.
- Understand clearly the order to be implemented and question any that are not understood. The nurse is responsible for intelligent implementation of medical and nursing plans of care.
- Adapt activities to the individual client. A client's beliefs, values, age, health status and environment are factors that can affect the success of a nursing action.
- Implement safe care by following correct steps and scientific principles.
- Provide teaching, support and comfort as required.
- View the client as whole and make the plan and implementation holistic.
- Respect the dignity of the client and enhance the client's self-esteem by providing privacy and encouraging client to make their own decisions.
- Encourage clients to participate actively in implementing the nursing interventions. Active participation enhances the client's sense of independence and control. The amount of desired involvement may be related to the severity of the illness and understanding of the intervention.
Supervising Delegated Care
If the care has been delegated to other health care personnel, the nurse responsible for the client's overall care must ensure that the activities have been implemented according to the care plan. Other caregivers are required to communicate their activities to the nurse by documenting them on the client's record, reporting verbally, or filling out a written form. The nurse validates and responds to any adverse findings or client responses. This may involve modifying the nursing care plan.
Documenting Nursing Activities
After carrying out the nursing activities, the nurse completes the implementing phase by recording the interventions and client responses in the nursing progress notes. The nurse must record the nursing intervention immediately or as early as possible after it is implemented. The recorded data must be up-to-date, accurate, and available to other nurses and health care professionals.
Nursing activities are communicated verbally as well as in writing. When client's health is changing rapidly, the head nurse and/or the physician may want to be kept up to date with verbal reports. Nurses also report 18client status at change of shifts or on client's discharge to another unit or institution, in person, in writing, or via a voice recording.
Evaluating
Evaluating is the final / fifth phase of the nursing process, in which the nurse determines the client's progress toward goal achievement and the effectiveness of the nursing care plan. The plan may be continued modified or terminated after the evaluation.
To evaluate means to judge or appraise. It is a planned, ongoing, purposeful activity in which clients and health care professionals determine (a) the client's progress toward achievement of outcomes/goals (b) the effectiveness of the nursing care plans. Evaluation is an important aspect of the nursing process because conclusions drawn from the evaluation determine whether the nursing interventions should be terminated, continued or changed.
Evaluation is continuous and when carried out during or immediately after implementing a nursing order/directive, enables the nurse to make on-the-spot modifications in an intervention. Evaluation performed at specific intervals (e.g. once a week for a home care client), shows the extent of progress toward achievement of outcome and enables the nurse to correct any deficiencies and modify the care plan as needed. Evaluation continues until the client achieves the health goals or is discharged from nursing care. Evaluation at discharge includes the status of goal achievement and the client's self-care abilities with regard to follow-up care.
Through evaluating, nurses demonstrate responsibility and accountability for their actions, and indicate interest in the results of the nursing activities carried out.
Relationship of Evaluating to other Nursing Process Phases
Successful evaluation depends on the effectiveness of the steps that precede it. Assessment data must be accurate and complete so that the nurse can formulate appropriate nursing diagnoses and desired outcomes. The desired outcomes must be stated in behavioural terms if they are to be useful for evaluating client responses. And without the implementing phase, in which the plan is put into action, there would be nothing to evaluate.
The evaluating and assessing phases overlap as assessment (data collection) is ongoing and continuous at every client contact. However, data are collected for different purposes at different points in the nursing process. During the assessment phase the nurse collects data for the purpose of making diagnoses. During the evaluation step, the nurse collects data for the purpose of comparing it to pre-selected goals and for judging the effectiveness of the nursing care.
Process of Evaluating
Before evaluating, the nurse identifies the desired outcomes (indicators), which will be used to measure client's goal achievement. Desired outcomes serve two purposes:
- They establish the kind of evaluative data that need to be collected and
- Provide a standard against which the data are judged. For example, given the following expected outcomes, any nurse caring for the client would know what data to collect:
- Daily fluid intake will not be less than 2500 ml.
- Residual urine will be less than 100 ml.
The process of evaluation has five components:
- Collecting data related to desired outcomes.
- Comparing data with outcomes.
- Relating nursing activities to outcomes.
- Drawing conclusions about problem status.
- Continuing, modifying or terminating the nursing care plan.
Collection of Data
Using the clearly stated, precise and measurable desired outcomes as a guide, the nurse collects data so that conclusions can be drawn about whether goals have been met. It is necessary to collect both objective and subjective data.
Comparing Data with Outcomes
Both the nurse and client play an active role in comparing the client's actual responses with the expected outcomes. For example, did the client drink 3000 ml of fluid in 24 hours? The nurse can draw one of three of the following conclusions:
- The goal was met; that is the client response is the same as the desired outcome.
- The goal was partially met; that is only the short-term goal was achieved and the long-term goal was not attained.
- The goal was not met.
After determining whether a goal has been met, the nurse writes an evaluative statement in the nurse's notes. An evaluative statement consists of two parts; a conclusion and a supporting data.
The conclusion is a statement that the desired outcome was met or not. The supporting data are the list of client responses that support the conclusion.
For example, goal met: oral intake at 300 ml more than output; skin turgor good, mucous membrane moist. In practice (in hospital units), care plans usually do not have a column for evaluation statements; rather, these are recorded in the nurse's notes.
Relating Nursing Activities to Outcomes
The aspect of the evaluating process relates to determining whether the nursing activities had any relation to the outcomes. It should not be assumed that a nursing activity was the cause of or the only factor in meeting, partially meeting or not meeting a goal. For example, if the weight gain of a prenatal client meets the expected level as stated in the care plan she must ensure that it relates to the instructions given to the mother only, or due to fluid retention related to pre-eclamptic toxemia. It is important to establish the relationship or lack of relationship of nursing actions to the client responses.
Drawing Conclusions about Problem Status
In order to determine whether the care plan was effective in resolving, reducing or preventing client problems, the nurse uses the judgments about goal achievement. When goals have been met, the nurse can draw one of the following conclusions about the client's problem:
- The actual problem stated in the nursing diagnosis has been resolved; or the potential problem is being prevented and the risk factors no longer exist. In these circumstances, the nurse documents that the goals have been met and discontinues the care for the problem.
- The potential problem stated in the nursing diagnosis is being prevented, but the risk factors are still present. In this case, the nurse keeps the problem on the nursing care plan.
- The actual problem still exists even though some goals are being met. For example, a desired outcome on a client's care plan is “will drink 2500 ml fluid daily”. Even though the data from intake-output record show this outcome had been achieved, other data (dry oral mucous membrane) may indicate that there is deficient fluid volume. Therefore the nursing interventions must be continued even though this goal was met.
When goals have been partially met or when goals have not been met the nurse may conclude on one of the following:
- The care plan needs to be revised. The revisions may need to occur during assessing, diagnosing or planning phases as well as implementing.
- The care plan does not need revision, because the client merely needs more time to achieve the goals.
Continuing, Modifying and Terminating the Nursing Care Plan
After drawing conclusions about the status of the clients' problems, the nurse modifies the care plan as indicated. Depending on policies of the hospital/agency, modifications may be made by marking portions using a highlighting pen or by drawing a line through portions of the care plan or writing “discontinued” and the data. This requires a review of the entire care plan and a critique of the nursing process steps involved in its development.
In addition to evaluating goal achievement for individual clients, nurses are also involved in evaluating and modifying the overall quality of care given to groups of clients. This is an essential activity of professional accountability.